-

Paul Anthony Kelly | Exercises in Fulfillment

Via Issue 207, Need for Speed

Written by

Juno Kelly 

Photographed by

Cody Lidtke

Styled by

Marc Anthony George

No items found.
BALENCIAGA shirt and tie. IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN watch. Talent’s own bracelet and ring.

This spring, 3,450 miles from New York and 27 years since John F. Kennedy JR. graced the Lower East Side, London’s streets were brimming with backwards cap-donning men. Their sartorial inspiration came by way of Love Story: John F Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette, an FX drama based—albeit loosely—on the late President Kennedy’s son and his wife Carolyn. Meanwhile, across the Atlantic, women were throwing furtive glances at JFK JR. lookalikes at a contest in Washington Square Park, who undoubtedly hoped to emulate even a fraction of the charm actor Paul Anthony Kelly did as the Kennedy scion.

The drama, produced by Ryan Murphy, saw Kelly cast in his breakout role. All square American (or in Kelly’s case, Canadian) jawline and gently buff physique, Kelly’s looks undoubtedly gave the actor and model—who until Love Story, had done little more than community theatre—a leg up. But according to the show’s executive producer Brad Simpson, the role was not easy to fill. “It was a real challenge to find that sort of guy—a guy that women and gay men are attracted to, but also guys want to hang out and have a beer with,” he told GQ.

BRUNELLO CUCINELLI jacket, shirt, and tie. SAINT LAURENT BY ANTHONY VACCARELLO sunglasses.

But even with a genetic headstart, mythologizing one of the shiniest national treasures in American history is no small feat; it was a responsibility that Kelly did not take lightly. “I had such a wealth of information to go back on. He was such a well-documented individual that I was able to go back and [study]…He used his mouth in a totally different way than I do…It was a great exercise in emulation.”

Yet on our video call from New Jersey, I’m struck by how different Kelly looks to his character. His hair is a mop of curls, his jaw shadowed by dark stubble, John-John’s usual suit swapped out for a hoodie. Kelly’s manner, however, is not dissimilar to how legend recounts JFK Jr.: he’s playful and boyish; down to earth despite being a bona fide winner of the genetic—and now fame—lottery. He answers my questions with earnest interest, resting his head on his hand as he looks into the Zoom box.

BALENCIAGA coat, shirt, pants, tie and shoes. IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN watch.

There’s a fleeting window at the outset of fame when its eventually vexing elements remain exciting; early proof of success. (Or, at least, when celebrities are willing to admit that they are). I’ve caught Kelly at this precise stage of his ascent. “People’s interactions with me are incredibly positive, all the time, overwhelmingly so. As an actor, you want to do a good job, and when people are coming up to you in the streets and they’re like, ‘I loved you in that,’ It feels really good…I never expected or even really wanted to be a leading man. Now that I have it, I’m so for it. It’s great. I’m incredibly grateful. You go somewhere and people are hollering your name and asking for autographs and pictures. I love it. I think it’s great. It really shows me how far I’ve come.” 

GUCCI jacket, sweater, and pants. JOHN HARDY necklace and bracelet (left hand). IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN watch. Talent’s own rings and bracelet (right hand).

Granted, it doesn’t hurt that between his sojourns to LA and New York, he can return to his enclave in Oregon, where he and his wife moved after the LA fires. “Having that respite in Oregon where we feel like it’s very much our vibe in what we want out of life [helps]: close to nature, lots of walks. The weather’s moody, which bodes very well for both of our creative souls.”

Kelly is also basking in the aftermath of his big break because, at 38, it’s been a long time coming. Despite nurturing a successful modeling career, Kelly spent decades having little luck with auditions, inciting him to join Group Rep Theatre, a community theatre in Los Angeles, to confirm that acting, in all its relentless disappointment, was a career worth fighting for. After performing every day for six weeks, he decided it was. (And is keen to get back on the stage). Still, mere weeks before his audition for Love Story, he entertained the possibility of paving a fork in the road. He and his wife were planning on starting a family, so considered moving back to Canada, to make the most of its healthcare and education.

“I would have gone into small engine repair in a small town in Ontario,” he tells me. “I was like, ‘Okay, cool. If I can’t get my goal of being an actor, I can still get my goal of being a father.’ You just do what you have to do. It’s not about you anymore. It’s about your little one. And I was willing to make that sacrifice. Would do it anytime.” Instead, within a matter of months, he was cast in Love Story, graced the covers of Interview, GQ Hype, and VMAN, and had fans all over the world.  Oh, and his wife fell pregnant with their first child. “Now I’m lucky that I’m in the position where it’s kind of still about me,” he jokes. He’s struck a good balance, I suggest. “Well, I’m a Libra.”

AMIRI jacket and shirt. IWC SCAUFFHAUSEN watch.

But it hasn’t all been gushing fans and glossy magazine spreads. Though Love Story’s final episode sees a stern therapist council John: “Lets just try not to editorialize;” Editorialize, the show did. The creators employed such dramatic licence that it was condemned by members of the Kennedy family and Daryl Hannah, Kennedy’s ex, who wrote a searing indictment of her portrayal for The New York Times. If Kelly were to go back, would he do anything differently? “No. Honestly, I don’t pay attention to it. All of us went into this project with complete sensitivity, and our hearts were in the right place. And, you know, once we got into it, it just felt right. The timing was perfect. I have such an affinity for John and Carolyn. I always thought he was a really cool guy. Now I know he is. And Carolyn was such an enigma. I feel a lot closer to them. Not in any family way whatsoever; I have no idea what it’s like to have stories and movies and television shows and books made about your family. But our hearts were in the right place. And I think this show really brought their story to the forefront.” 

Ironically, starring in a show that put a limelight-shy woman back into the headlines helped equip Kelly for a similar glare. “It highlights a lot of what fame does to you, in a sense. The parallels between what Carolyn was going through and what I find myself going through. You know, it’s different. We don’t have paparazzi outside of our house, because everyone’s just got a phone. That’s definitely different. The times have changed, but it’s still very relevant and very parallel.”

ZEGNA coat, sweater, and shirt. LOUIS VUITTON tie. IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN watch.

In addition to helping him appreciate fame, Kelly believes his age has primed him to cope with it, and all its Faustian benefits. “If I got something along those lines that catapulted me into this realm I find myself in now, if that happened at 25, I think that I would be abusing it for the parties and social interactions and all of that extra nonsense that comes with fame. I probably would have made headlines in some negative ways,” he laughs. “Paul Anthony Kelly found drunk in the middle of the street.” 

Few things spell success for a budding actor like being welcomed into the Ryan Murphy-verse. Murphy—the creator of shows like Glee, Feud, and American Crime Story—is prolific, his projects are high profile, and he’s notoriously loyal to the actors he casts. So it’s no surprise that after starring in Love Story, Kelly landed a role, no audition necessary, in American Horror Story. “Ryan’s vote of confidence made me more confident in being able to do it,” he says of appearing in the cult show’s thirteenth season. “We shot a lot of this in the same stages that we shot Love Story in. So it really felt like going back home.”

SAINT LAURENT BY ANTHONY VACCARELLO coat, shirt, pants, tie, and shoes.

In American Horror Story, Kelly plays the charming Mr. Nas, a veiled moniker for Satan, a far cry—not least because of his shock of blonde hair—from both Kelly and John-John. It was also his first time professionally  playing a character that wasn’t based on a real person: “It was my first time creating something,” he says. “John was the box that I had to play within, and I think I really colored in as much as I could. But this is like, ‘Just have at it, blank sheet. These are the colors you can play with, but go for it’...I feel like with each project, I’m getting more support and more confidence and keen to take bigger swings.”

SAINT LAURENT BY ANTHONY VACCARELLO coat, shirt, pants, tie, and shoes. IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN watch. Talent’s own bracelet.

And American Horror Story won’t be the last time Kelly pushes against the casting type Love Story laid the groundwork for. He’s been cast as the villain in the sequel to box office hit The Housemaid, The Housemaid’s Secret, in which he’ll portray the vigilante housekeeper’s (Sydney Sweeney) latest target. Only this time, he had to audition the old fashioned way, doing a chemistry read with co-star Kirsten Dunst (“We hit it off,” he says), and the dressing room won’t be so familiar. “I’m nervous. I’m incredibly nervous,” he admits. “This is my first movie. It’s my third project. I’m still very new. My feet are just getting wet here, but I feel like I’m on the fast track. And it’s great. It’s a great feeling.” 

Here lies the root of Kelly’s charm: an enthusiasm that betrays the kind of modesty that, when coming from the parasocially adored, usually feels contrived. “I still am several shades of green,” he laughs.Still, he knows he’s going places. “But they’re getting darker.” Getting into the forest greens now, I offer. “Exactly,” he confirms. “That’s my favorite color.”

LOUIS VUITTON jacket, shirt, tie, pants, and shoes. IWC SCHAFFHAUSEN watch. FALKE socks. Talent’s own bracelet and rings.

Photographed by Cody Lidtke

Styled by Marc Anthony George

Written by Juno Kelly

Grooming: Jessica Ortiz at Kalpana

Flaunt Film: Mynxii White

Production Assistant: Adelaide Young

Location: W New York – Union Square

No items found.
No items found.
#
Paul Anthony Kelly, Issue 207, Need for Speed, Balenciaga, IWC Schaffhausen, Gucci, John Hardy, Amiri, Zegna, Louis Vuitton, Saint Laurent by Anthony Vaccarello, Falke, Brunello Cucinelli
PREVNEXT